We bake them fresh everyday!

We handcraft your favorite cookies fresh everyday!

Avoid the lines! - Order Pickup Now Available! Same day orders must be placed by 11:00AM!

Why choose us?

We are a gourmet cookie company based in the Indianapolis area. We deliver fresh baked gourmet cookies and cookie cakes. Our artisan cookies are handcrafted with only the finest of ingredients: real butter, pure vanilla, fine chocolates, select nuts, etc! Not As Famous Cookie Company™ was founded with the mission of supplying delectable baked products to discriminating consumers who value quality!

Allergy statement: Menu items may contain or come into contact with WHEAT, EGGS, PEANUTS, TREE NUTS, and MILK. 

Small company that delivers Big service. I cannot say enough about this company’s excellent customer service! At a time where customer service is a hit or miss, those at Not As Famous Cookie Company really do set the customer service bar high! Professional, courteous, convenient and accommodating. The bakery catered two events for my company. After scrolling through many photos of products on the bakery’s website, I decided to order a few cookie cakes. Much to my surprise, the cookie cakes were not only beautiful, they were delicious! And the buttercream icing was so fresh! If anyone is looking for a delicious, sweet treat with quality ingredients, this bakery is the way to go! You’re sure to impress those who attend your event as well!

Dr. Brittany Grady
Cresta Bella Dental

The cookie cake that I ordered for my birthday was amazing! The chocolate chip cookie was perfectly baked. The icing was delicious. My order was ready at the designated time. Superb customer service. I will definitely be ordering more cookies from here!

Kristin McCorkle
Zionsville, IN

Obsessed with these cookies!! You won’t be disappointed and they will even have your favorite flavors ready if you order ahead. Getting to talk to the sweet owners is just an added bonus!

LeeAnn Irwin
Zionsville, IN

30 East Poplar Street

Zionsville, IN 46077 USA

Store Hours

Tuesday - Friday

10:30 AM - 5:00 PM


10:30 AM - 5:00 PM

Sunday & Monday